The creative process resulted in a multifunctional urban complex that retains the social accessibility of the former market while extending its role into a contemporary civic infrastructure. The Phuket Urban Service Center combines market stalls, retail spaces, municipal and public services, parking, loading facilities, public amenities, green areas, and flexible spaces for urban activities. The project is therefore not conceived as a single-purpose building, but as an interface between everyday commerce, public service, mobility, and collective urban life.
The principal spatial result is a system of continuity connecting internal programs with surrounding streets and activity areas. A grid-based organisation coordinates market modules and structural logic, while lines of sight and circulation establish legibility across the building. Permeable edges, shaded thresholds, internal voids, open public areas, and planted surfaces reduce the separation between the building and the city. In this sense, circulation is not treated only as movement efficiency; it becomes a medium through which users encounter different programs, people, and urban conditions.
The façade was developed as an urban interface rather than as an applied image. Project documentation identifies the façade as a mediator between interior and exterior, a contextual element supporting orientation and recognition, and a placemaking mechanism connecting internal activities with public life. References to Phuket’s Sino-European architectural identity were therefore abstracted through rhythm, scale, depth, shading, and transitional space instead of being reproduced as literal stylistic decoration.
The project demonstrates that designing through postmemory does not require the physical replication of a lost or previous condition. Instead, it requires the recognition that memories of place are partial, mediated, and continuously reconstructed through present experience. The former market survives within PUSC not as a preserved visual object, but through renewed conditions of exchange, encounter, movement, adaptability, and public participation.
The central conclusion is that architecture can act as an active medium between urban traces and future experience. PUSC proposes a shift from preserving an image of the past to reconstructing the relationships that allow the past to remain meaningful. The project consequently defines urban postmemory as a design practice through which inherited spatial traces are selected, critically translated, and opened to new collective interpretations.
1. Stakeholder Negotiation and Implementation Constraints
The official project report records a second public and agency consultation on 30 November 2021. Its documented design priorities include retaining existing vendor stalls, increasing parking provision, creating a landmark for district development, and supporting a night-time walking-street node. A reported meeting outcome selected a development alternative with an estimated THB 50–75 million investment range, a building height not exceeding 23 m, and over 10,000 m² of usable area. These are reported planning positions, not verbatim statements attributable to individual vendors or residents (Department of Public Works and Town & Country Planning [DPT], 2022, 1.11–1.12).
The report estimates THB 75 million in financial construction costs (2021 price basis), and reports an economic internal rate of return of 17.70% and benefit–cost ratio of 1.48 at a 12% discount rate (DPT, 2022, §1.14). These historic appraisal figures are not current tender prices or evidence of completed implementation. Construction phasing, temporary vendor relocation, infrastructure integration, and maintenance of proposed environmental-envelope components remain issues requiring detailed implementation verification. The architectural drawings document design resolution, not construction completion or post-occupancy social outcomes.
2. Comparative Discussion: Southeast Asian Market Transformations
A regional comparison helps distinguish three approaches to continuity in historic public markets: preservation of a recognised architectural artefact, rehabilitation of a functioning market, and critical translation of everyday spatial relationships into a new architectural framework. The cases below are used as analytical comparators, not as evidence that their designers adopted Hirsch’s postmemory theory.
Lau Pa Sat (Former Telok Ayer Market), Singapore, exemplifies architectural and institutional continuity through conservation and adaptive reuse. Its nineteenth-century cast-iron market structure survives as a protected national monument, although its commercial role has shifted from a wet market to a hawker and food destination (National Heritage Board, n.d.; Urban Redevelopment Authority, n.d.). The case shows how a recognisable historic building can anchor urban identity even as the surrounding city and everyday practices change. In contrast, PUSC does not primarily seek to preserve a historic market structure as an artefact; it interprets continuity through market activity, permeability, circulation, and new civic programmes. This distinction is crucial: formal survival and continuity of social-spatial relationships are related but not equivalent.
Central Market (Phsar Thmey), Phnom Penh, Cambodia, offers a closer comparison in terms of the negotiation between commercial continuity and physical intervention. Its rehabilitation combined restoration of the 1937 market, upgrades to sanitation and surrounding infrastructure, and new market facilities. The design team reports that phased construction was organised to keep approximately 3,000 merchants trading during the works (Agence Française de Développement, n.d.; Arte Charpentier, n.d.). This precedent is particularly relevant to PUSC’s documented objective of retaining existing traders while expanding parking and public-service functions. However, it also exposes an unresolved implementation issue: a proposed programme can accommodate traders on paper without demonstrating how their livelihoods will be maintained during construction. The PUSC documentation should therefore not be interpreted as proof of an operational relocation or phasing strategy.
Read together, the cases sharpen PUSC’s proposed contribution. Lau Pa Sat prioritises the survival and adaptation of a historic architectural object; Phnom Penh Central Market combines fabric conservation with operational and infrastructural renewal; PUSC proposes a new multifunctional civic building that retrospectively translates selected market practices and urban spatial traces. This is a comparison of documented design strategies, not a ranking of their social outcomes. No post-occupancy evidence has yet established that PUSC users will experience mediated memory as anticipated. Its originality therefore lies in an explicit interpretive framework for relating inherited practices to architectural decisions, rather than in a demonstrated superiority over conserved markets.
3. Limitations and Contribution
The project’s theoretical contribution is deliberately limited. Hirsch’s postmemory concerns mediated relationships to intergenerational traumatic histories; everyday commercial change must not be equated with that experience. Here the term operates as a critical, retrospective lens for examining how selected traces of urban practices may be translated into spatial opportunities. The available documentation cannot demonstrate that users have acquired particular memories or that collective recollection has been transmitted. A future comparative study of Southeast Asian public-market transformations and post-occupancy research would be necessary to test such claims.